Building more just, healthy relationships between people and establishing a more sustainable dynamic with the Earth

Category: Uncategorized Page 1 of 7

Last Chance to Tell City Council: Vote “No” on NISP

First, please send an email to cityleaders@fortcollins.gov with the simple message of “pause the vote and get more technical understanding of water security risk” before voting to join NISP.” Write Agenda Item # 22, Ordinance 148, in the subject line of your email. It is important to “inundate” the Mayor and City Council with email to show that residents of Fort Collins are deeply concerned that the City do the right thing.

Next – If you can – attend the City Council meeting on Tuesday, November 3rd at Council Chambers, City Hall, 300 Laporte Ave. Sign up in advance on the City’s website here to comment in person, Zoom, or by phone, before the 5:30 deadline November 3rd. You may speak during the Open General Public Comment starting at 6:00 pm, or after Agenda Item # 22 is presented.

TALKING POINTS

WATER SECURITY: The most consequential uncertainties of joining NISP versus continuing with Halligan expansion: 1) reliability of senior vs. junior water rights (The City’s ability to access its Senior Water Rights stored in Glade depends on contractual terms that are not yet established in an MOU between Fort Collins and Northern); 2) availability of exchange water; 3) climate-driven shifts in runoff timing; 4) muti-year drought performance; 5) City’s actual usable storage and the City’s ability to withdraw on demand “senior water” the City stores in Glade.

LONG-TERM STORAGE AND DROUGHT PREVENTIONS: NISP has GREAT uncertainty due to the need to share Glade water with other NISP Participants and have access to our Senior Water regulated by NISP’s control of dam operations, especially under drought conditions. Also, projected climate change shows summer snowmelt shifting to spring rain runoff, with uncertain implications for NISP water rights needed to fill Glade.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS: NISP will permanently transform the Poudre River for reasons that the Corps of Engineers assessments do not show, because the Corps are only required to assess 2 Factors: surface area of certain wetlands and dry surface areas of the river. City Staff and our City Council appear to lack understanding of the transformational deterioration of the Poudre River that NISP will cause, because diversions during high spring flows will dry out the river. The flow mitigation measures proposed by NISP will not prevent the rapid decline of the river and ripaian ecosystem through Fort Collins. We will lose the single most important natural resource through Fort Collins, the Poudre River.

THE FINANCIAL COMPARISONS OF THE HALLIGAN EXTENSION AND NISP LACK CLARITY: Dropping the Galeton reservoir expansion from the down-scaled NISP decreases costs. But by how much? It also drops annual water delivery from 40,000 AF to 20,000 AF, but with the same environmental impact. The approved NISP permit relies on modelling and delivery schedules that assumed 40,000 AF inputs from Galeton. Is the NISP 404 permit approved in 2020 (based on modelling that included Galeton Reservoir as a majority source on fill water for Glade) still valid, legally and factually? The aging Hallagan Dam will still need ~$100 million in repair costs. Is that reflected in the costs of joining the new, 20,000 AF NISP?  If the Would this offset the asserted “cost savings” of NISP? Shouldn’t the Halligan Dam repair costs be part of the costs of moving ahead with NISP, instead of hidden elsewhere?

WHY IS THIS POSITION REVERSAL BEING DONE NOW, when the decision process has been deliberately withheld from the Public, even when Fort Collins residents and former City Council’s have overwhelmingly reject joining NISP for? The members of the Fort Collins City Council have allowed virtually no time for public notification or input before and between their first vote on October 19th and their scheduled final vote tomorrow evening. Why must they rush to judgment?The Fort Collins City Council has until February 1, 2027 to tell the Corps if they want to withdraw or continue with their request for a 404 Permit to build the Halligan Reservoir expansion. Tomorrow evening is the last chance for residents to insist that the Fort Collins City Council pause on the vote on joining NISP until AFTER they have allowed an open and transparent public process, supported by a legitimate, comprehensive technical analysis of water security risk of Halligan versus NISP.

COUNCIL SHOULD PAY ATTENTION TO THE CITY’s ONE WATER DIRECTOR, WHO SAID “MANY THINGS HAVE CHANGED OVER THE PAST 18 MONTHS”. The Corps is operating in a changed political environment. This Regional Director of the Corps of Engineers has suggested the Corps will not grant a 404 permit for Halligan. The Corps wants the City to drop Halligan expansion and join NISP. The Corps cannot dictate the City’s actions, and its actions are intended to bully the City. But the City can push back if it’s in our best interests. U.S. Senator Sheldon (D-RI), in an October 2025 oversight meeting, said “The Army Corps of Engineers has become the most politicized it has ever been in modern history.”  An Administration that believes that climate change is real would also understand the tragedy of killing our river. Taking advantage of this political moment to push through a project whose EIS was not acceptable in the last Administration isn’t legislation that the Fort Collins City Council should vote to join without a full accounting of all of its implications.

THE COUNCIL AND MAYOR WERE ASSURED BY THE DIRECTOR OF UTILITIES THAT THERE ARE MANY “OFF-RAMPS’, partly because it is only a 1- year commitment. That seemed to be an argument that helped convince several City Council members to vote for the Ordinance.  The residents and rate payers of Fort Collins deserve to know what these ‘off-ramps’ are, before Tuesday evening. Inflated costs, unsecured access to our Seniotr Water in Glade, and Climate-change shocks will impact our future water security and these risk factors have not been properly modeled and scrutinized.

WHY BAIL OUT NISP?: $18 million to join an already failing project that won’t have water in coming out of our taps for 10-15 years. Four of the original Participants in NISP have dropped out. They’ve downscaled to a smaller NISP but is this viable? There aren’t other buyers for this speculative project, which is dependent on thousands and thousands of imagined new rooftops East of Fort Collins to succeed. If Fort Collins doesn’t join NISP, NISP will continue to flail  financially and could collapse. The City has already put about $50 million into the Halligan planning phase. There is no reason for Fort Collins to chase the failing, and fading, dreams of NISP.

The terms and conditions of the draft MOU between the City and Northern have not yet been agreed-upon:  The City does not have a firm contract about the terms of transferring our Senior Water into Glade, and how to retrieve it under drought. It doesn’t make sense to develop the terms and conditions of the MOU AFTER Council votes to gives $18 million of our tax dollars to Northern. 

There are no current action alerts.

Tell City Council NOT to join NISP!

Heads up, everyone! After opposing NISP for two decades, the Fort Collins City Council is thinking of joining this failing project!

As reported in an Oct. 14 article in the Colorado Sun by Michael Booth (Fort Collins giving up Halligan water expansion, joining troubled NISP and Glade Project), Fort Collins staff is recommending to City Council that we reverse the City’s current position opposing the Northern Integrated Supply Project (NISP), and use our tax dollars to bail out this economically failing project.

The first reading of this under-the-radar plan will take place at the City Council meeting Tuesday, October 20, beginning at 6 PM. This plan is “Item 0.19” on this agenda with support material beginning on p.374 in this meeting packet. City Council voted to oppose NISP in 2008, 2015, 2018, and, most recently, in resolution 2020-078 when “City staff has concluded that NISP will be harmful to Fort Collins and to the City.” With little rationale, City staff have reversed their long-standing opinion, while river scientists continue to believe NISP will be a disaster for the Poudre. Without substantial public protest and demand for an open public process, the City’s reversal of its long-standing opposition to NISP is hasty and lacks input from a public that has been engaged in NISP for two decades. 

Please alert everyone you know and urge them to tell City Council NOT to reverse their 2015 decision opposing NISP, and to make this a deliberative, transparent public process. Please email your Council members, and, if you can, attend Tuesday’s meeting in person. You must register here if you wish to speak.

The reasons why this would be a terrible decision for meeting future FC water needs, for protecting the Poudre River, and for maximizing economic investments in water security, are detailed in this letter to City Council from John Sanderson. Sanderson is the former Science Director of the Colorado Nature Conservancy with long involvement in the NISP process.

Here are four key talking points from recently retired CSU Professor LeRoy Poff, a river ecologist who has been actively engaged in scrutinizing NISP and its environmental impacts since 2007: 

• Halligan Reservoir on the N. Fork of the Poudre has very senior water rights, providing high water reliability for Fort Collins, vs. NISP’s very junior water rights. Fort Collins joining NISP reduces our water supply reliability

• Fort Collins has already spent $50M on the Halligan project, including several million for anticipated environmental improvements on the North Fork associated with expanding the size of the Halligan Dam.

• The “environmental mitigation” promised by NISP is contingent on filling Glade Reservoir over many years, assuming good river flows in the future. Climate change promises many future dry years, when NISP cannot exercise its junior water rights.

• Fort Collins joining NISP likely risks irreversibly degrading the much-loved Poudre River and its local riparian corridor.


THANK YOU for considering urging City Council to NOT reverse their 2015 decision opposing NISP, and to make this current decision a deliberative, transparent public process.

Tell Mayor Francis and City Council: No Rollback of the 100% Non-carbon Goal, No More Renewable Energy Credit Sales!

In 2018, the Platte River Power Authority (PRPA), which supplies electricity to Fort Collins, Loveland, Longmont, and Estes Park, approved a goal of generating 100% non-carbon electricity by 2030. Due to its own malfeasance, PRPA management now wants to roll that goal back by removing any “due date.” They’ll get around to it when they get around to it. It’s pie in the sky for us when we die!

To make matters worse, PRPA is now selling the “Renewable Energy Credits” (RECs) for its wind energy production to others. This means that Fort Collins and the other PRPA owner communities can no longer count that production toward their renewable energy or climate goals. Fort Collins is expected to see its climate pollution reduction compared to 2005 levels drop from 28% in 2024 to only 19% in 2025, thanks to this change. If the PRPA removes the due date from its non-carbon goal, it can continue to sell off its RECs indefinitely.

Please speak out at the Fort Collins City Council meeting at 6:00 p.m. on Tuesday, October 6th to tell Mayor Emily Francis, who serves on the PRPA Board, and members of council that you don’t want the 100% non-carbon goal to go away, and that you want REC sales to stop immediately. You will need to sign up to speak here. Select the option to speak during public comment. If you are unable to attend in person, please send an e-mail to City councilmembers and the City Manager at cityleaders@fortcollins.gov. Here is what we are calling for:

  1. A specific non-carbon percentage goal for 2030 to be set, of between 85% and 95%.
  2. Designation of a new date for achieving 100% non-carbon generation, no later than 2040.
  3. Either a halt to plans to build a new fracked gas generating plant, or the decommissioning of at least part of the PRPA’s existing fracked gas generating fleet. The PRPA currently owns 388 MW of fracked gas generators. That’s a lot! If the PRPA does not do one of those two things, other utilities in the Southwest Power Pool will continue calling on the PRPA’s fracked gas generators to sell them power during the middle of the day in peak ozone season as they have done this past summer, polluting our air, damaging the climate, and making it impossible to ever come close to 100% non-carbon.
  4. Finally, an immediate halt to REC sales to those outside the PRPA’s member communities. Those sales are expected to generate $2 million per year according to this memo, which will go toward electric rate reductions. The PRPA sold 3,274,542,00 kWh to its owner communities last year, according its 2025 Annual Report. The $2 million in REC sales would result in a rate reduction of $0.0006 per kWh, reducing the average monthly residential electric bill by about 40 cents. No one is going to notice that miniscule decrease. We should not trade away our hard work on our climate goals over the past quarter century for next to nothing.
    1. For added context, the PRPA’s unnecessary new fracked gas plant will cost at least $623 million – more with financing costs included. If the PRPA really wants to keep rates low, it shouldn’t build that gas plant.

Fort Collins Sustainability Group

P.O. Box 672, Fort Collins, CO  80522

Ask Joe Neguse to Cosponsor House Bill Blocking Attack on Cuba

On March 26th, Representatives Pramila Jayapal and Gregory Meeks introduced H.R. 8103 to prevent the use of taxpayer dollars to introduce military force in Cuba without prior Congressional authorization. The bill currently has 34 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives. Joe Neguse is not one of them.

Please write to Joe Neguse’s foreign policy aide, Ishmael Brown (Ismael.Brown@mail.house.gov), and tell him that you’d like to see Joe Neguse cosponsor H.R. 8103. You can personalize the following message, or simply send it as is:

Dear Mr. Brown:

Please encourage Representative Neguse to cosponsor H.R. 8103, which would prohibit the use of funds to use military force in or against Cuba. Cuba poses no threat to the people of the United States. Any use of force against that country would be blatantly illegal, as were the attacks on Venezuela and Iran earlier this year.

As one of Representative Neguse’s constituents, I’d like to see him get out in front of this one.

Thank you,

Your Name

Your Address

Make a Public Comment on Plutonium Pit Production 

In October of 2024, a federal judge in South Carolina found that the United States Department of Energy (DOE) and its National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) failed to assess the environmental impact of their plutonium pit production plan at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) in New Mexico and Savannah River Site (SRS) in South Carolina.

A plutonium pit is the softball-sized bomb core that begins the chain reaction in every modern US thermonuclear weapon. Currently, there is no demonstrated need for new plutonium pits to ensure the safety or reliability of the existing US nuclear weapons stockpile. In fact, these new pits will be for entirely new nuclear weapons. This kind of production involving extremely dangerous radioactive materials puts workers and nearby communities at risk. The NNSA is seeking to expand production to at least 30 plutonium pits per year at the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) in New Mexico and at least 50 pits per year at SRS by 2030, which has never previously produced pits, for new nuclear weapons. NNSA pushed forward with the project without the required public review of the multi-site project or an assessment of alternatives, in violation of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). 

This ruling results in the mandatory review of pit production at DOE sites across the country, including management of radioactive waste. Under NEPA, this provides a critical opportunity for public scrutiny of and formal comment on these assessments. The Draft PEIS was released April 10 and the 90-day comment period is now open.

Take action by submitting a written comment to PitPEIS@nnsa.doe.gov by July 16! Communities across the country will be affected, not just ones that live close to DOE sites, as nuclear materials will be transported on highways. With the current administration’s dismantling of the NEPA process, which has resulted in the DOE now scrapping draft environmental impact statements and public comments, this could be the last time the public gets to adequately scrutinize a nuclear weapons project. 

We have a standalone website that has more information and will be updated with comment trainings and additional resources. Visit pitpeis.com for more information!

Tell Vice President J.D. Vance to Invoke Section 4 of the 25th Amendment

On April 7th, President Donald Trump stated that he was prepared to end Iranian civilization after starting an illegal war last month that has taken an increasing toll on Iranian civilians. While that threat was fortunately not carried out, it is a frightening example of Trump’s increasingly unhinged behavior. Many mental health professionals believe that Trump is suffering from Frontotemporal dementia, which NCALF explored during the salon held on April 10th.

Representative Jasmine Crockett (D-TX) recently called on Vice President J.D. Vance to invoke Section 4 of the 25th Amendment to formally declare President Trump “as unfit to discharge the powers and duties mandated by the Constitution.”  While there’s little light or air between J.D. Vance’s outlook on the world and Donald Trump’s, Vance has the advantage of apparently not suffering from dementia and is therefore less likely to perpetrate extreme harm on the people of Iran or the rest of humanity.

Please write to Vice President Vance using the form available at this link and amplify Representative Jasmine Crockett’s demand.  Please put the request in your own words, or simply use the following language:

Dear Vice President Vance:

Representative Jasmine Crockett is right.  Donald Trump is a danger to humanity.  It is high time that you, along with the President’s Cabinet and the Congress, invoke Section Four of the Twenty-Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution by formally declaring this President as unfit to discharge the powers and duties mandated by the Constitution.

Sincerely,

Your Name

Update and Action Alert on PRPA Gas Plant Permit

On March 13th, the Colorado Air Pollution Control Division (APCD) released a revised draft permit for the PRPA’s proposed Rawhide gas plant. The permit documents are available here. The Fort Collins Sustainability Group and others have since reviewed the permit, and have concluded that while it represents an improvement over the first draft permit, it could do much more to protect public health and the environment. We are therefore asking people to send comments to the APCD again asking that they make additional improvements. This should be done prior to deadline of April 12th.

The new draft permit does establish annual limits for how long the new fleet of five gas turbines (collectively, the gas plant) may run, and how much “hazardous air pollutants” (HAPs) that fleet may release. It requires that Rawhide Unit #1 (the coal plant) shut down within 180 days of the date when all five gas turbines become operational, and no later than December 31st, 2029. However,

  1. The new permit allows the gas plant to operate at equivalent full output for 45% of the entire year. That’s a lot of hours – 3,942, to be precise.
  2. The new permit allows the gas plant to emit up to 25 tons of HAPs per year. That’s a lot of air toxins that wouldn’t be released by wind turbines, solar panels, or batteries.
  3. Perhaps most surprisingly, the new permit allows the gas plant to emit more HAPs in the summer – ozone season on the front range – than during other seasons. More specifically, it allows:
    1. 30% of total annual pollutants to be released in December – February
    2. 15% of total annual pollutants to be released in March – May
    3. 40% of total annual pollutants to be released in June – August (aka ozone season)
    4. 15% of total annual pollutants to be released in September – November.

Please write to the APCD at cdphe_apcd_airpermitcomments@state.co.us and state in the subject line that you are commenting on Draft Construction Permit 24LR0705. Tell them that the final permit should:

  1. Include more stringent limitations on hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) during June – August. Letting the gas plant release 40% of annual total HAPS during ozone season is unconscionable.
  2. Reduce the total amount of HAPs permitted from 25 tons to the lowest number possible. HAPs – including carbon monoxide, particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, and volatile organic compounds – lead to poor health and kill people and animals.
  3. If 25 tons of HAPs is really the absolute minimum that APCD can accept, reduce the number of turbines permitted from five to three. Three turbines can produce more than enough electricity than the draft permit assumes is needed. Building fewer turbines will help reduce the spiraling cost of PRPA’s new gas plant, which will be paid for by the residents of Fort Collins, Loveland, Longmont, and Estes Park over the coming decades through their electricity bills.

Please use your own words if you can, and explain why at least limiting the size of the gas plant is important to you. But sending something is better than nothing! Be sure to e-mail your letter to the APCD before the deadline, April 12th.

Tell Senator Bennet to Support Wolf Reintroduction

Senator Michael Bennet has expressed opposition to reintroducing wolves to Colorado.  That needs to change! Please reach out to Senator Bennet to tell him that you want to see wolf reintroduction continue.  Calling is best, but e-mailing is better than nothing! Here is a sample phone script, and his contact information:

Phone script:

Hello, my name is [Name] and I live in [Town]. I’m calling to ask Senator Bennet to withdraw his support for suspending Colorado’s wolf reintroduction program. A pause now would delay recovery and undermine the voter mandate. Please ask the Senator to publicly support continuing the program. Thank you.

Contact information

  1. Washington, D.C.: 202-224-5852
  2. Fort Collins: 970-224-2200
  3. E-mail: Visit this link.

Call on Congress to Pass War Powers Resolution Against War on Iran

War has broken out, and is now quickly spiraling into a regional conflict.

The predictable death toll is climbing, including over 150 children at a girls’ school in Iran bombed on day one.

American casualties have also now been confirmed, with Trump indifferently saying there will likely be more.

Yet Congress has yet to actually debate, much less vote on the record, on opposition or support of Trump and Netanyahu’s folly.

That could, and should, end this week. We expect votes on War Powers Resolutions (WPR) in the House soon, and the Senate is scheduled to vote on Tuesday, 3/3. That means it’s time to step up. It’s time to be loud. It’s time to demand, in no uncertain terms, that we want this war to stop NOW!

It is time to call your representative and both senators to demand support for War Powers Resolutions. Your members of Congress are deciding how to respond this minute, and that means they need to hear the demands of their constituents — and the overwhelming pro-peace majority — to vote YES on the WPR.

MAKE URGENT CALLS TO YOUR ELECTED OFFICIALS TODAY:

1) Call the Congressional switchboard at 202-224-3121
2) Ask to be connected to your rep’s office, and repeat for each of your two senators. Make 3 calls!!!
3) Once connected, give them this message (in as many of your own words as possible):

Hello, my name is ____________ and I’m a voting constituent from (your city). The Trump administration has launched unauthorized strikes on targets across Iran. Congress must act immediately to use every ounce of its influence and constitutional authority to prevent further violence and all-out war — one which a majority of Americans reject.

As your constituent, I insist that you support the bipartisan War Powers Resolution to stop President Trump from continuing to wage unauthorized war against Iran. It is expected that a vote could be as soon as this week. It is past time for Congress to fulfill its Constitutional authority and vote to require authorization of any military action against Iran. I demand that the representative/senator support the bipartisan War Powers Resolution. Thank you.

Alternatively, e-mail your Representative and Senators with the same message using the links below:

Joe Neguse

John Hickenlooper

Michael Bennet

Page 1 of 7

-->