First, please send an email to cityleaders@fortcollins.gov with the simple message of “pause the vote and get more technical understanding of water security risk” before voting to join NISP.” Write Agenda Item # 22, Ordinance 148, in the subject line of your email. It is important to “inundate” the Mayor and City Council with email to show that residents of Fort Collins are deeply concerned that the City do the right thing.
Next – If you can – attend the City Council meeting on Tuesday, November 3rd at Council Chambers, City Hall, 300 Laporte Ave. Sign up in advance on the City’s website here to comment in person, Zoom, or by phone, before the 5:30 deadline November 3rd. You may speak during the Open General Public Comment starting at 6:00 pm, or after Agenda Item # 22 is presented.
TALKING POINTS
WATER SECURITY: The most consequential uncertainties of joining NISP versus continuing with Halligan expansion: 1) reliability of senior vs. junior water rights (The City’s ability to access its Senior Water Rights stored in Glade depends on contractual terms that are not yet established in an MOU between Fort Collins and Northern); 2) availability of exchange water; 3) climate-driven shifts in runoff timing; 4) muti-year drought performance; 5) City’s actual usable storage and the City’s ability to withdraw on demand “senior water” the City stores in Glade.
LONG-TERM STORAGE AND DROUGHT PREVENTIONS: NISP has GREAT uncertainty due to the need to share Glade water with other NISP Participants and have access to our Senior Water regulated by NISP’s control of dam operations, especially under drought conditions. Also, projected climate change shows summer snowmelt shifting to spring rain runoff, with uncertain implications for NISP water rights needed to fill Glade.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS: NISP will permanently transform the Poudre River for reasons that the Corps of Engineers assessments do not show, because the Corps are only required to assess 2 Factors: surface area of certain wetlands and dry surface areas of the river. City Staff and our City Council appear to lack understanding of the transformational deterioration of the Poudre River that NISP will cause, because diversions during high spring flows will dry out the river. The flow mitigation measures proposed by NISP will not prevent the rapid decline of the river and ripaian ecosystem through Fort Collins. We will lose the single most important natural resource through Fort Collins, the Poudre River.
THE FINANCIAL COMPARISONS OF THE HALLIGAN EXTENSION AND NISP LACK CLARITY: Dropping the Galeton reservoir expansion from the down-scaled NISP decreases costs. But by how much? It also drops annual water delivery from 40,000 AF to 20,000 AF, but with the same environmental impact. The approved NISP permit relies on modelling and delivery schedules that assumed 40,000 AF inputs from Galeton. Is the NISP 404 permit approved in 2020 (based on modelling that included Galeton Reservoir as a majority source on fill water for Glade) still valid, legally and factually? The aging Hallagan Dam will still need ~$100 million in repair costs. Is that reflected in the costs of joining the new, 20,000 AF NISP? If the Would this offset the asserted “cost savings” of NISP? Shouldn’t the Halligan Dam repair costs be part of the costs of moving ahead with NISP, instead of hidden elsewhere?
WHY IS THIS POSITION REVERSAL BEING DONE NOW, when the decision process has been deliberately withheld from the Public, even when Fort Collins residents and former City Council’s have overwhelmingly reject joining NISP for? The members of the Fort Collins City Council have allowed virtually no time for public notification or input before and between their first vote on October 19th and their scheduled final vote tomorrow evening. Why must they rush to judgment?The Fort Collins City Council has until February 1, 2027 to tell the Corps if they want to withdraw or continue with their request for a 404 Permit to build the Halligan Reservoir expansion. Tomorrow evening is the last chance for residents to insist that the Fort Collins City Council pause on the vote on joining NISP until AFTER they have allowed an open and transparent public process, supported by a legitimate, comprehensive technical analysis of water security risk of Halligan versus NISP.
COUNCIL SHOULD PAY ATTENTION TO THE CITY’s ONE WATER DIRECTOR, WHO SAID “MANY THINGS HAVE CHANGED OVER THE PAST 18 MONTHS”. The Corps is operating in a changed political environment. This Regional Director of the Corps of Engineers has suggested the Corps will not grant a 404 permit for Halligan. The Corps wants the City to drop Halligan expansion and join NISP. The Corps cannot dictate the City’s actions, and its actions are intended to bully the City. But the City can push back if it’s in our best interests. U.S. Senator Sheldon (D-RI), in an October 2025 oversight meeting, said “The Army Corps of Engineers has become the most politicized it has ever been in modern history.” An Administration that believes that climate change is real would also understand the tragedy of killing our river. Taking advantage of this political moment to push through a project whose EIS was not acceptable in the last Administration isn’t legislation that the Fort Collins City Council should vote to join without a full accounting of all of its implications.
THE COUNCIL AND MAYOR WERE ASSURED BY THE DIRECTOR OF UTILITIES THAT THERE ARE MANY “OFF-RAMPS’, partly because it is only a 1- year commitment. That seemed to be an argument that helped convince several City Council members to vote for the Ordinance. The residents and rate payers of Fort Collins deserve to know what these ‘off-ramps’ are, before Tuesday evening. Inflated costs, unsecured access to our Seniotr Water in Glade, and Climate-change shocks will impact our future water security and these risk factors have not been properly modeled and scrutinized.
WHY BAIL OUT NISP?: $18 million to join an already failing project that won’t have water in coming out of our taps for 10-15 years. Four of the original Participants in NISP have dropped out. They’ve downscaled to a smaller NISP but is this viable? There aren’t other buyers for this speculative project, which is dependent on thousands and thousands of imagined new rooftops East of Fort Collins to succeed. If Fort Collins doesn’t join NISP, NISP will continue to flail financially and could collapse. The City has already put about $50 million into the Halligan planning phase. There is no reason for Fort Collins to chase the failing, and fading, dreams of NISP.
The terms and conditions of the draft MOU between the City and Northern have not yet been agreed-upon: The City does not have a firm contract about the terms of transferring our Senior Water into Glade, and how to retrieve it under drought. It doesn’t make sense to develop the terms and conditions of the MOU AFTER Council votes to gives $18 million of our tax dollars to Northern.